Taylor is hired as Hugh after Matthew approves him, pushed by Natasha. Matthew is a general manager under pressure from his father, and Taylor has to hide her identity from him as well as from the suspicious Natasha. Over time Hugh becomes the resort's most popular Santa. He helps Natasha's daughter air her frustrations, and the advice inspires Matthew to be better.
Natasha investigates Hugh's file, finds nothing, and then traces the social security number to Taylor Jacobson. Taylor's secret is exposed when her daughter Zoey is injured snowboarding. Taylor runs to her side and forgets she is dressed as Santa, so she is forced to reveal herself. A video of the unmasking goes viral. Matthew is heartbroken and keeps his distance, but he takes ownership of the decision to hire Hugh, so Taylor is not punished even though Natasha wanted legal action.
Zoey tells her mother she is proud of her. At the resort's closing Christmas concert Matthew gives a speech about Santa being kindness, generosity and love. Taylor comes on stage and apologizes, explaining that she needed a job and wanted to help Zoey. They reconcile, kiss and perform together. The next morning everyone gathers at Taylor's home, and she is revealed to be the resort's director of family events.