"She Passed Out On Cary! No Wonder . . . She's just discovered his favorite aunts have poisoned their 13th gentleman friend!"
Arsenic and Old Lace - Characters & Cast
Character Analysis
Mortimer Brewster
Cary Grant
Motivation
To protect his aunts from going to prison, to get his new wife safely away from his homicidal family, and to prevent himself from succumbing to the Brewster madness.
Character Arc
Mortimer begins as a smug, self-assured intellectual who has just broken his own anti-marriage rules. Upon discovering the bodies, he spirals into absolute panic and physical exhaustion trying to protect his aunts. He ultimately finds salvation when he learns he is not a biological Brewster, allowing him to embrace a happy, sane future.
Abby and Martha Brewster
Josephine Hull and Jean Adair
Motivation
To provide charity and peace to lonely old men who have nothing left to live for, viewing murder as a compassionate public service.
Character Arc
The aunts remain completely static throughout the film, maintaining their cheerful, matronly demeanor from start to finish. Their absolute refusal to acknowledge the horror of their crimes is the anchor of the film's comedy.
Jonathan Brewster
Raymond Massey
Motivation
To find a safe place to undergo plastic surgery, hide from the law, and violently assert dominance over his childhood home and brother.
Character Arc
Jonathan arrives as a terrifying, dominant force seeking a safe haven. As the night progresses, his authority is constantly undermined by the absurdity of his family, until he is finally outsmarted, arrested, and infuriated to learn his aunts tied his murder record.
Dr. Herman Einstein
Peter Lorre
Motivation
Survival, avoiding the police, and finding a drink to steady his constant nerves.
Character Arc
Einstein enters as Jonathan's nervous lackey. As the danger escalates, he acts as the voice of reason and self-preservation, eventually seizing the opportunity to quietly slip away from the madness and escape arrest.
Teddy Brewster
John Alexander
Motivation
To fulfill his duties as the President of the United States, including digging the Panama Canal and attending cabinet meetings.
Character Arc
Teddy experiences no growth; he lives entirely within his own historical delusion, cheerfully carrying out orders and blowing his bugle until he is peacefully relocated to the Happy Dale Sanitarium.