The Best of Youth
A sweeping Italian epic where the turbulent currents of history carve the divergent paths of two brothers, a poignant visual novel of love, loss, and the enduring search for self.
The Best of Youth
The Best of Youth

La meglio gioventù

"The Possibilities Were Endless..."

22 June 2003 Italy 367 min ⭐ 8.1 (572)
Director: Marco Tullio Giordana
Cast: Luigi Lo Cascio, Alessio Boni, Adriana Asti, Sonia Bergamasco, Fabrizio Gifuni
Drama History Romance
The Personal and the Political Idealism vs. Disillusionment The Complexity of Family Mental Health and Social Responsibility
Box Office: $2,693,053

The Best of Youth - Characters & Cast

Character Analysis

Nicola Carati

Luigi Lo Cascio

Archetype: The Idealist/Healer
Key Trait: Compassionate

Motivation

Driven by a deep-seated empathy and a desire to heal others and correct injustice. His motivations are rooted in a belief in human connection, progress, and the power of understanding. He is always ready to engage with the world and the people in it.

Character Arc

Nicola begins as a sensitive and open-minded young man who, after the traumatic event with Giorgia, channels his idealism into a constructive path. He becomes a psychiatrist dedicated to humane reform, a loving father, and the stable center of the family. His journey is one of endurance and adaptation; he faces profound personal loss—the estrangement of his wife Giulia and the suicide of his brother—but emerges not broken, but with a deeper, more mature understanding of life. He learns the limits of his ability to 'save' others but never loses his fundamental compassion, ultimately finding a new form of happiness and family with Mirella.

Matteo Carati

Alessio Boni

Archetype: The Tragic Hero/The Outsider
Key Trait: Tormented

Motivation

Matteo is motivated by a fierce, almost punishing sense of justice and a yearning for an unattainable purity in a flawed world. He seeks order and rules to contain the chaos he feels internally, but this ultimately suffocates him.

Character Arc

Matteo starts as a brilliant, passionate, but deeply troubled and volatile young man. His idealism is rigid and absolute. The failure to rescue Giorgia shatters him, leading him to abandon his studies and seek refuge in the rigid structures of the army and police force. His arc is a tragic descent into emotional isolation and self-destruction. He consistently pushes away those who love him, like Mirella, unable to reconcile his inner turmoil with the world around him. His journey culminates in his suicide, a final act of despair from a man who could not find a way to live with his own perceived failures and internal demons.

Giulia Monfalco

Sonia Bergamasco

Archetype: The Revolutionary
Key Trait: Radical

Motivation

Motivated by a profound indignation at social and economic injustice, she seeks to fundamentally change the world. Her initial desire for a better society evolves into a conviction that violent action is the only way to achieve it.

Character Arc

Giulia is introduced as a passionate, intelligent university student who falls in love with Nicola. Initially, her political convictions align with the hopeful activism of the era. However, her frustration with the slow pace of change and the injustices she perceives leads her down a path of increasing radicalization. Her arc shows her transformation from an idealist into a hardened member of the Red Brigades, a choice that forces her to abandon her family, including her daughter, Sara. She becomes a tragic figure, sacrificing her personal life for a violent ideology, representing the destructive potential of extremism.

Giorgia

Jasmine Trinca

Archetype: The Innocent/The Catalyst
Key Trait: Vulnerable

Motivation

Her primary motivation is survival. Initially trapped in a state of fear and withdrawal, her journey is about reclaiming her voice and her ability to connect with the world, a process facilitated by Nicola's patient kindness.

Character Arc

Giorgia's arc is one of survival and slow, difficult healing. She begins as a victim of an abusive psychiatric system, rendered almost mute and catatonic by electroshock therapy. Her initial 'rescue' by the brothers fails, but she re-emerges years later when Nicola discovers her in another institution. Under Nicola's care, she gradually regains a semblance of life and autonomy. Though she remains scarred by her past, her journey is a testament to resilience. She acts as a catalyst for the brothers' diverging paths and remains a powerful moral touchstone throughout the film.

Cast

Luigi Lo Cascio as Nicola Carati
Alessio Boni as Matteo Carati
Adriana Asti as Adriana Carati
Sonia Bergamasco as Giulia Monfalco
Fabrizio Gifuni as Carlo Tommasi
Maya Sansa as Mirella Utano
Valentina Carnelutti as Francesca Carati
Jasmine Trinca as Giorgia Esposti
Andrea Tidona as Angelo Carati
Lidia Vitale as Giovanna Carati
Claudio Gioè as Vitale Micavi
Paolo Bonanni as Luigino
Giovanni Scifoni as Berto
Riccardo Scamarcio as Andrea Utano
Camilla Filippi as Sara Carati