We All Loved Each Other So Much
A bittersweet Commedia all'italiana capturing the fading embers of youthful idealism, painting a poignant fresco of friendship and disillusionment against the backdrop of a changing Italy.
We All Loved Each Other So Much
We All Loved Each Other So Much

C'eravamo tanto amati

"A many splendored thing."

21 December 1974 Italy 124 min ⭐ 8.3 (621)
Director: Ettore Scola
Cast: Nino Manfredi, Vittorio Gassman, Stefania Sandrelli, Stefano Satta Flores, Giovanna Ralli
Drama Comedy
Disillusionment and Lost Ideals Friendship and Betrayal The Passage of Time and Memory Cinema as a Reflection of Life

We All Loved Each Other So Much - Characters & Cast

Character Analysis

Gianni Perego

Vittorio Gassman

Archetype: The Compromised Idealist
Key Trait: Ambitious

Motivation

Driven by a deep-seated ambition for success, wealth, and social status, even at the cost of his personal relationships and political ideals.

Character Arc

Gianni begins as an idealistic law student and partisan fighter. Post-war, his ambition leads him down a path of moral compromise. He leaves Luciana for a strategic marriage to Elide, the daughter of a corrupt construction magnate, ensuring his wealth and success. He abandons his socialist principles, becoming a successful but cynical and lonely man, ultimately alienated from his old friends and his former self.

Antonio

Nino Manfredi

Archetype: The Everyman
Key Trait: Steadfast

Motivation

To live a simple, decent life, maintain his friendships, and find love and stability. He is motivated by a fundamental sense of loyalty and a good heart.

Character Arc

Antonio is the most grounded and consistently principled of the group. He starts as a hospital orderly and remains one throughout his life, representing the steadfast, working-class conscience of the trio. He experiences heartbreak and disappointment, particularly in his unrequited love for Luciana, but finds a measure of contentment in a simple life with his family. He remains true to his leftist ideals, though he is less vocal and intellectual about them than Nicola.

Nicola Palumbo

Stefano Satta Flores

Archetype: The Tragic Intellectual
Key Trait: Idealistic

Motivation

A passionate and uncompromising belief in his political and cultural ideals, particularly the power of cinema to reflect truth and enact social change.

Character Arc

Nicola is a passionate, intellectual idealist, and a fervent cinephile. His refusal to compromise his rigid political and artistic beliefs leads to professional and personal failure. He loses his teaching job over an argument about the film "Bicycle Thieves," leaves his family, and moves to Rome to become a critic, only to struggle in poverty. He represents the tragedy of uncompromising idealism in a world that rewards pragmatism, becoming a bitter and disillusioned dreamer.

Luciana Zanon

Stefania Sandrelli

Archetype: The Catalyst / The Muse
Key Trait: Hopeful

Motivation

Initially driven by the dream of becoming a successful actress, she is ultimately seeking love, stability, and a sense of belonging.

Character Arc

Luciana is the woman who all three men love at various points. An aspiring actress, she is a symbol of their shared desires and the object over which their friendship fractures. Her own life is one of struggle and disappointment; her dreams of stardom never materialize. She moves from a relationship with Antonio to a passionate affair with Gianni, and is later cared for by Nicola. Ultimately, she finds a quiet life with Antonio, representing a retreat from grand ambitions to simple, reliable affection.

Cast

Nino Manfredi as Antonio
Vittorio Gassman as Gianni Perego
Stefania Sandrelli as Luciana Zanon
Stefano Satta Flores as Nicola Palumbo
Giovanna Ralli as Elide
Aldo Fabrizi as Romolo Catenacci
Marcella Michelangeli as Gabriella
Elena Fabrizi as Anna Catenacci, Romolo's wife
Fiammetta Baralla as Maria
Dino Curcio as Palumbo
Isa Barzizza as Elena
Livia Cerini as Rosa
Carla Mancini as Lena
Lorenzo Piani as Enrico
Amedeo Fabrizi as Amedeo, Romolo's son