Witness for the Prosecution
A a labyrinthine courtroom drama, this film noir unwraps deception like a fine cigar, leaving a lingering ash of moral ambiguity.
Witness for the Prosecution
Witness for the Prosecution

"The most electrifying entertainment of our time!"

17 December 1957 United States of America 116 min ⭐ 8.2 (1,549)
Director: Billy Wilder
Cast: Tyrone Power, Marlene Dietrich, Charles Laughton, Elsa Lanchester, John Williams
Drama Crime Mystery
Deception and Manipulation The Fallibility of Justice Love and Betrayal Perception vs. Reality
Budget: $3,000,000
Box Office: $9,000,000

Witness for the Prosecution - Characters & Cast

Character Analysis

Sir Wilfrid Robarts

Charles Laughton

Archetype: The Mentor / Wounded Healer
Key Trait: Cynical Brilliance

Motivation

His primary motivation is the intellectual challenge of a seemingly impossible case. Restricted by his health, he craves the thrill and mental stimulation of the courtroom, which he sees as his true purpose. He is driven by a belief in his own superior ability to discern truth and manipulate the legal system to serve what he believes is justice.

Character Arc

Sir Wilfrid begins as a brilliant, cynical, and seemingly infallible barrister, albeit one weakened by a heart attack. His arc is one of intellectual pride leading to a fall. He takes Leonard's case out of a desire to prove his mind is still sharp. He masterfully conducts the defense, believing he has uncovered the truth and outsmarted the prosecution. The final revelation that he was merely a pawn in Christine's elaborate game shatters his self-assurance, leaving him humbled but also invigorated to take on a new, more just cause: defending Christine.

Christine Vole/Helm

Marlene Dietrich

Archetype: The Femme Fatale / The Trickster
Key Trait: Masterful Deceiver

Motivation

Her sole motivation is her all-consuming love for Leonard Vole. She is willing to commit perjury, create an elaborate deception, and sacrifice her own freedom to ensure his. When that motivation is destroyed by his betrayal, it is instantly replaced by a powerful desire for revenge.

Character Arc

Christine is introduced as a cold, enigmatic German wife. Her arc is a series of calculated transformations. She first appears as a potential alibi, then transforms into a vindictive, hateful witness for the prosecution, and later a disguised Cockney informant. The final twist reveals her true arc: a deeply devoted lover who masterminded the entire plot to save her husband. This image is shattered in the final moments when, upon discovering his betrayal, she transforms once more into an agent of immediate, violent justice. She is consistently underestimated and proves to be the most intelligent and ruthless character in the film.

Leonard Vole

Tyrone Power

Archetype: The Innocent / The Shadow
Key Trait: Duplicitous Charm

Motivation

Initially, his motivation appears to be survival and proving his innocence. However, his true motivations are greed (for Mrs. French's inheritance) and self-preservation at any cost. He is driven by a sociopathic ability to manipulate those around him, particularly women who love him, for his own gain.

Character Arc

Leonard Vole presents himself as a charming, likable, and slightly naive man wrongfully accused of a terrible crime. Throughout the trial, he maintains this persona of the innocent victim, gaining the trust of Sir Wilfrid and the sympathy of the audience. His arc is a complete inversion upon his acquittal. The mask of innocence drops to reveal a smug, cold-blooded murderer who not only killed Mrs. French but also callously used his wife's devotion. This shocking reveal recasts his entire performance as a masterful deception.

Miss Plimsoll

Elsa Lanchester

Archetype: The Guardian / The Comic Relief
Key Trait: Overzealous Care

Motivation

Her motivation is simple and unwavering: to keep Sir Wilfrid Robarts alive by enforcing his doctor's strict regimen. She is dedicated to her professional duty, even in the face of Sir Wilfrid's constant attempts to undermine her authority regarding his cigars, brandy, and workload.

Character Arc

Miss Plimsoll is Sir Wilfrid's fiercely protective and overbearing private nurse. Her character does not have a significant arc but serves as a constant and necessary foil to Sir Wilfrid. She is the guardian of his health, engaging in a continuous battle of wits with her cantankerous patient. Their comedic sparring, a highlight of the film, was enhanced by the fact that actors Charles Laughton and Elsa Lanchester were married in real life.

Cast

Tyrone Power as Leonard Vole
Marlene Dietrich as Christine
Charles Laughton as Sir Wilfrid
Elsa Lanchester as Miss Plimsoll
John Williams as Brogan-Moore
Henry Daniell as Mayhew
Ian Wolfe as Carter
Torin Thatcher as Mr. Myers
Norma Varden as Mrs. French
Una O'Connor as Janet
Francis Compton as Judge
Philip Tonge as Inspector Hearne
Ruta Lee as Diana
Patrick Aherne as Court Officer (uncredited)
Walter Bacon as Bar Patron (uncredited)