The narrative unravels several major twists and climaxes across Season 1:
- The Truth of Bit-na's Death: The original human Judge Kang Bit-na was not a criminal; she was ambushed and murdered by Jeong Tae-gyu (Serial Killer J) after discovering dark secrets tied to Assemblyman Jeong Jae-geol.
- Serial Killer J & Satan: Serial Killer J, who murdered Detective Han Da-on's family years prior and killed Officer Kim So-young, is revealed to be Jeong Tae-gyu. Meanwhile, Satan himself has been hiding on Earth inside Assemblyman Jeong Jae-geol to avoid Hell's wardens.
- Secret Angel Gabriel: Angel Gabriel was disguised as homeless woman Oh Mija and a young man.
- The Prophecy and Sacrifice: Prophecy states that if Justitia and Da-on remain together, one will die. Bael commands Justitia to release Jung Tae-gyu in human court so she can kill him infernally; if she sentences him to death in human court, Bael will kill her.
- The Finale Climax: Justitia chooses moral integrity over self-preservation. She sentences Jung Tae-gyu to death in human court, restoring public faith in justice. Bael executes her, but Angel Gabriel intervenes due to her noble sacrifice, granting her resurrection.
- The Ending Resolution: Bael grants Justitia a final deal: punish 10 more unrepentant sinners within a year to earn the right to become fully human and live out a natural life on Earth with Han Da-on, setting up the foundation for Season 2.