Vertigo - Ending Explained

The central twist of "Vertigo" is revealed in a flashback from Judy's perspective about two-thirds into the film: the woman Scottie knew as Madeleine never died. Judy was hired by Gavin Elster to impersonate his wife, Madeleine, as part of an elaborate plot to murder the real Mrs. Elster. Elster knew of Scottie's acrophobia and used him as the perfect witness. When Judy, as Madeleine, ran up the bell tower, Scottie was unable to follow. At the top, Elster was waiting with the body of his real wife, which he threw from the tower. The inquest ruled it a suicide, and Scottie's testimony, colored by the story of Madeleine's 'possession,' sealed the case.

This early reveal completely changes the film's dynamic. The suspense is no longer about what happened to Madeleine, but about Scottie's psychological state and Judy's agonizing predicament. We watch with dread as Scottie, unaware of the truth, forces the woman he once loved (and who loves him back) to erase her own identity and become a ghost. His obsession is revealed not just as romantic longing, but as a form of necrophilia—he is trying to bring a dead woman back to life. Every moment of Judy's transformation is fraught with tension and pathos. The Carlotta Valdes necklace becomes the crucial clue. When Scottie sees Judy wearing it, he finally understands the deception. His decision to take her back to the scene of the crime is an act of cruel psychological retribution. The ending is crushingly ironic: Judy, startled by the sudden appearance of a nun, falls to her death from the tower, tragically and accidentally recreating the fake suicide she was paid to perform. Scottie is left standing at the precipice, cured of his vertigo but having lost everything, a man completely broken by his obsession.

"Vertigo" is a film rich with ambiguity, leading to numerous interpretations. One of the most prominent alternative readings suggests that the entire film, after the opening sequence, is a dream or hallucination occurring in Scottie's mind while he is in a catatonic state in the sanatorium. This theory posits that the implausible plot points, the dreamlike quality of the cinematography, and the surreal geography of San Francisco are all products of his traumatized psyche. Midge's line, "mother's here," is interpreted as his actual mother visiting him in the hospital, and the younger Midge is a fantasy.

Another interpretation focuses on the ending's ambiguity. It is unclear whether Judy's final fall is an accident, a suicide driven by guilt and fear, or even a form of cosmic justice for her role in the murder. The appearance of the nun is so sudden and spectral that it could be interpreted as a supernatural intervention or a manifestation of Judy's guilt. The film's alternate ending, which shows Gavin Elster being pursued by authorities, offers a more conventional sense of closure but is widely seen as undermining the film's tragic, personal focus on Scottie's psychological ruin. Feminist critiques have also offered powerful interpretations, viewing the film as a stark deconstruction of male obsession and the violent ways in which men project their fantasies onto women, ultimately destroying their identity.