The overarching mystery reveals that Hyun-soo was never a serial killer or his father's accomplice. When the Gagyeong village foreman was murdered, it was actually Hyun-soo's sister Hae-soo who struck him in self-defense to stop a sexual assault; Hyun-soo deliberately took the murder weapon and assumed the blame so his sister could live a normal life.
Following a hit-and-run accident 15 years prior, Hyun-soo was struck by Baek Hee-sung. To hide their comatose son's crime, Hospital Director Baek Man-woo and his wife Gong Mi-ja struck a deal with Hyun-soo: he took on their comatose son's legal identity, living comfortably while they concealed his fugitive past. The real Baek Hee-sung was Do Min-seok's actual protege and partner in the Yeonju serial killings. Upon awakening from his 15-year coma, Hee-sung resumes his killing spree, murders the Baek family housekeeper, stabs Hae-soo (mistaking her for Ji-won), and frames Hyun-soo.
In the climactic confrontation, the police corner the real Hee-sung. Hee-sung steals an officer's gun and aims at Ji-won; Hyun-soo dives in front of the bullet, taking the hit to the head before police shoot Hee-sung dead. Hyun-soo survives brain surgery but loses all memories of his 14-year marriage to Ji-won. At his trial, Hae-soo and Ji-won clear him of all historical murder charges. Though initially frightened that his feelings for Ji-won were an illusion, Hyun-soo visits his old workshop, recognizes the profound depth of his innate connection to Ji-won and Eun-ha, and weeps as they reconcile to begin a new, truthful life together.