The film is framed through Becket Redfellow's confessional narration from a prison cell while awaiting execution. Through flashbacks, we witness his methodical elimination of six family members: staging yacht drownings, tampering with darkroom chemical vents, and sabotaging megachurch rigging.
The critical twist occurs when Becket confronts Patriarch Whitlow Redfellow (Ed Harris). Before Becket can execute him, Whitlow suffers a fatal natural heart attack, leaving Becket with clean hands for the ultimate kill. Becket successfully assumes the multi-billion-dollar Redfellow estate.
However, the dark irony unfolds in true Kind Hearts and Coronets fashion: Becket is arrested, convicted, and sentenced to death not for any of the murders he actually committed, but for a death he was falsely framed for by Julia Steinway. In the closing sequence, Becket secures a last-minute pardon or escape path through his lawyers, only to realize he left his detailed, written diary chronicling every single murder sitting openly on the warden's desk, guaranteeing his ultimate ruin.