At hockey camp, Anxiety systematically discards Riley's original core beliefs, prompting Riley to alienate her friends, sneak into Coach Roberts' office to read her private notebook, and overexert herself. During the final scrimmage, Riley's panic leads her to body-check her friend Grace, landing her in the penalty box and triggering a severe panic attack depicted as a blinding orange whirlwind.
When Joy returns, she discovers that Riley's old Sense of Self ("I am a good person") no longer fits. Realizing that identity cannot be forced or curated, Joy steps into the storm and tells Anxiety, "You don't get to choose who Riley is."
All nine emotions embrace the new Sense of Self, producing a complex, multi-colored identity embracing contradictory truths: "I make mistakes," "I am kind," "I'm not good enough," "I am trying." Riley uses somatic grounding to recover, apologizes to her friends, and plays for the joy of the game. The film ends before revealing whether Riley made the FireHawks varsity roster, signifying that her self-worth is no longer defined by external validation.