The opening narration is a deliberately deceptive device. Geum-hwa calls her twin a demon who fed on her leg in the womb, and the film encourages us to see the twin as a monster. The Deer Mountain killer Na-han (known as Gwangmok within the sect) is presented as a sympathetic hunter of evil girls born in 1999. The sect believes 81 evil ones will be born and must be killed to protect the light.
The truth reverses this. Na-han, a disciple deceived by his 'Father', goes to Geum-hwa's home intending to strangle her. He is interrupted by birds and is frightened off by the sister, who grabs his leg from beneath the shed door. An aide in the sect tells him the girl in the shed is the 'snake' of the prophecy. When he finally meets her, she says she has waited for him and that she is the one who consoles him in his nightmares after he sheds blood. She sings the song from his dreams, and tells him to find the person with six fingers whom he calls Father and to kill him.
The 'Father' is revealed as Kim Je-seok, the cult founder, who looks like a young henchman but does not age. Pastor Park's contact Nechung Tenpa had said that the Master was born in 1899, is immortal, and has twelve fingers. The 'light' that the sect protects is therefore the false prophet's own life, and the 'snake' is his natural enemy. The sister foretells that earth will become sky and sky will become earth, and this is literally fulfilled when the car driven by Kim flips. The sect's murders are thus a way to sustain a man's immortality.
The film ends with a sense of reversal rather than triumph. The twin everyone treated as a demon was the instrument of release, while the supposed holy one was the true evil. Pastor Park, who started as a cynic, is left with unresolved questions about faith. The Herod and Christmas references reinforce the parallel between innocents killed to protect a ruler's power.